1. The Agent
      2. The Team
      3. Contact

          My team is here to serve. Our unique backgrounds, training and experience have prepared us well to help meet your insurance needs. Additionally, as residents of your community, we understand how important it is to be there for you - our trusted friends and neighbors. Together, we're building strong partnerships that help everyone succeed.

          • :
          • English
          • :
          • (855) 433-0004
          a couple of women standing on the porch of a house
          a woman with long hair

          Carolyn Volstorf

          Customer Service Representative
          Carolyn has been with Michelle and American Family insurance for over 15 years, with over 20 years insurance experience. She is fully licensed and is ready to help with any and all of your insurance needs!!!!
          a woman with a painted face

          Tina Naughton

          Agency Branch Manager
          Tina has been with Michelle and American Family insurance for over 27 years. She is fully licensed and her smiling face is ready to help with any and all of your insurance needs!!!!
          a woman with long hair and glasses

          Leann Davis

          Agency Branch Manager
          Leann Davis has many years in the insurance industry. She has been working in the Plymouth office for years. She is ready to help with any and all of your insurance needs!