Our team has over 80 years of combined insurance experience. We value the relationships we establish with our clients. We strive to provide white glove service and exceed expectations.

  • :
  • English
  • :
  • (855) 425-8213
a group of women posing for a photo outside

Amy Miller

Marketing Specialist
No Photo Available

Caitlin Rutten

Marketing Specialist
a person smiling for the camera

Cheryl Mitchell

Sales Specialist – All Lines
Cheryl has worked at American Family Insurance for 20 years. She was previously an agent in Worthington before joining our team in 2015. Her pride and joy are her 13 grandchildren
a person standing in front of a framed picture

Janet Marie

Customer Service Representative
Janet joined our team in 1997. She has licenses in OH and IN. From Pittsburgh originally
a person with long hair

Lisa Faytle

Customer Service Representative
Faye worked in our office 20 years ago and came back two years ago after raising her two adult children. She loves The Green Bay Packers and her Bermese Mountain Dogs! Her biggest fan is her husband of 26 years