Norton Seal
New home under construction

The Pros and Cons of Building a Home vs. Buying a Home

When you’re ready to purchase your very own home there’s always the home buying vs. building conundrum. There are pros and cons to both options. Of course, the decision is all yours and you’ll be basing it on your unique lifestyle. But let’s look at a few of the reasons you might want to build or buy a home.


Table of Contents:

The Pros of Building a Home

The Cons of Building a Home

The Pros of Buying a Home

The Cons of Buying a Home

Financing a New Build vs. an Existing Home

Build or Buy, American Family Insurance Has a Homeowners Policy for You

The Pros of Building a Home

“That sounds too expensive,” or “I don’t know if I can wait that long.” These are common answers to that inner dialogue home shoppers have to the question: “should I build a house?”

When you decide if you are going to build a house from scratch, it can be both very exciting and a bit scary. We’ve compiled this list of pros and cons for building or buying your next home to help you with that tough decision. Here are some of the main reasons why you should build your own house.

It’s brand new

When you build a new home, everything is just that — new! So, the odds of you needing to make any repairs within the first few years are slim to none. This gives you a longer time to settle in and enjoy your home without having to worry about making repairs.

Customize your home

It’s not always easy to find exactly what you want in an existing house. If you choose to build a house, you’ll have total control over the design of your home. You get to customize the floorplan in a way that makes sense to you and your family.

Avoid the bidding war

When the market is hot, homes can sell quickly, making the home-buying competition fierce. Depending on your area, finding a home that has the features you want can be very difficult and frustrating. And then, when you do find it, you might end up on the losing side of a bidding war. But when you build a home, you never have to worry about outbidding other buyers or the stress that comes from home shopping.

Really move-in ready

Even the most move-in ready house may still have a couple things you want to change, even if it’s just the color of the walls. But when you build a home, it’s exactly how you want it, from the flooring to the cupboard hardware. This means you can sit back and start enjoying your home from day one.

Build with better technology

Smart homes are becoming more and more common as people get used to the convenience and added safety it can provide. Even if the home you build isn’t packed with tech from the get-go, it is often tech ready. This means everything from security measures to electric gadgets — your new home could be a smart home in no time! In addition to all the benefits you get from having a smart home, you may also earn a discount on your homeowners insurance, just for being a trendsetting techie.

New homes are energy efficient

When you care about being energy efficient, you can make a big difference by building your home. You get to focus on bringing top of the line technology and energy savings into your home. And you get to do so in a customized way that focuses on what means the most to you.

Build a house that’s on top of the trends

One of the reasons to build a house is that new homes come with modern trends and cutting-edge style. Forget about renovating that outdated bathroom, when you build your own home you get to pick the style you want, down to the smallest details. Your home is magazine-glamorous from day one.

Current on codes

Building codes do change over time, always with an eye on protecting the residents, the neighborhood or the environment. Quite often the changes incorporate new and safer technology. With a newly built home you know you’re up to code and nothing has been grandfathered in.

Cost efficient

While it typically costs more in the beginning to build a home, you may recoup those expenses quickly and see a bigger payoff in the long run. When you build a house, there are no costly repairs for appliances, updates or remodeling. Most homes are built in newer neighborhoods that are very desirable. Add to that the annual savings you’ll realize with newer, more efficient appliances and construction techniques, and you’ve got some real financial benefits.

The feeling

Don’t forget the emotional aspect of building your own home. There’s nothing quite like knowing that it’s all yours and no one has lived there before. You get to start fresh and feel like everything in the home has your stamp on it. And it’s all been customized, just for you. This is perhaps the biggest one of all the reasons to build a house.

Back to top

The Cons of Building a Home

Although building your own home can be a thrilling experience, it may not be right for your family. There are many factors to consider, and your budget and the time you’ve allotted to get settled into your new home are crucial to your decision.

It takes more time to build a home from scratch

It can take more than six months to build a new home. So, if you’re in a hurry to move, building may not be the best option compared to buying.

A new home build can be quite expensive

When considering the cost of building vs. buying a house, building a house from the ground up comes with a hefty price tag, and can often be more costly upfront than buying an existing home.

Back to top

The Pros of Buying a Home

For many, buying a home is just as satisfying as building one. Although it is a big investment, there are some excellent advantages to purchasing a home that’s already been built. Here are three pros owning your own home!

Lower costs and an expedited timeline

Though building your own home may be great, buying a home and making upgrades over time can help cut down on up-front costs.

Buying a pre-built home is a faster route to closing

In most cases, when buying a home, the buyer can move in immediately after closing. There is no wait time or temporary housing to worry about, which is perfect for movers on a deadline.

Location opportunities

With existing homes, you can choose virtually any neighborhood or area. This is especially nice if you have a specific location in mind!

Back to top

The Cons of Buying a Home

Purchasing an existing home is an excellent investment. However, it might not be ideal for your family’s unique lifestyle. Here are some cons of buying a home to consider before home purchase.

Unexpected costs and "hidden fees" to consider

With older homes, the odds of you having to make repairs are higher than with a new, recently built home. You never fully know until you’ve lived in a house for a bit what repairs are essential to the health of the home, so it’s hard to budget for these fixes.

It’s a fixed layout, so it can’t truly be customized

Designing and building your own home gives you a lot of freedom when it comes to creating an interior layout and floor plan. Since the house is already built, you’re limited in terms of altering the existing floor plan. However, if your budget (and home design) allows for it, you could add on say, an enclosed patio for more square footage, or turn the garage into an extra room.

Remodeling/Upgrade costs

When buying a home, you might have to invest some time and money to bring the home up to current decorating standards by removing wallpaper, changing paint colors or updating flooring. Which could be great for those DIY masters out there, but maybe not for others.

Back to top

Financing a New Build vs. an Existing Home

Another key aspect to consider when thinking about your next home is financing. Closely consider the following factors when weighing the cost of building a house vs. buying house.

Know the 28/36% rule

Mortgage lenders use this guideline to determine how much home you can afford. It means that 28% of a family’s pre-tax income is the max amount they can spend on a new mortgage. The second part of the equation means that your debt should not exceed 36% of your pre-tax income.

Consider your future too

Even if you can afford the cost of the new proposed mortgage based on the 28/36% rule, this doesn’t mean that as your family grows, you’ll still be able to manage those payments. Consider your earning potential and if its sustainable; also have a solid understanding of that student loan debt you may not have started paying off yet.

Location limitations

Do you have a specific neighborhood in mind for your next move? If so, building might not be for you. To build a house, you need a plot of land, and you may not be able to find one in your preferred living area.

Back to top

Build or Buy, American Family Insurance Has a Homeowners Policy for You

These pros and cons are a great guide when you’re first thinking about whether to buy or build a home, but ultimately the decision is yours. What works better with your timeline? Your lifestyle? Your budget?

Before you even move the first piece of furniture into your beautiful, new home, give your American Family Insurance agent a call. You’ll also need a new homeowners insurance policy whether you build or buy a home. The great news is, you can customize your coverage. This gives you the confidence that comes from knowing you’re protecting what matters most to you.


This article is for informational purposes only and includes information widely available through different sources.


How would you rate this article?

Related Topics: At Home , Owning A Home , Home Insurance